Hold My LetterVol. XIV · Spring MMXXVI
Shop
← Back to Blog
Milestones

The Letter to Your Firstborn Before Baby Number Two

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Share this letter

For a few more weeks, your firstborn has no idea they’re about to become an older sibling. They know the words, probably. They’ve heard “baby” enough times to point at your stomach on cue. But they don’t know what it means, and in a very short while they will.

That gap, between knowing the word and knowing the thing, is the reason to write a letter to your firstborn before the second baby comes. It’s the last stretch of time when your family is the shape it’s been since they were born, and nobody keeps a record of it, because everyone is busy assembling a crib.

I should say up front that I don’t have children. I have a husband, two dogs, a drawer of fountain pens, and a company that holds sealed letters until the date you pick. So I’m not going to pretend to know what that third trimester feels like with a toddler on your hip. But I think a lot about the letters people mean to write and don’t, and this one has a deadline built in.

Why a Letter to Your Firstborn Matters Now

There’s a common belief that a new sibling is a kind of crisis for the oldest child. The research is calmer about it. In a review of 30 studies on the transition to siblinghood, published in Psychological Bulletin in 2012, University of Michigan psychologist Brenda Volling found that the evidence “did not support a crisis model of developmental transitions”. What she found instead was variety: the arrival of a sibling can be “a time of disruption, an occasion for developmental advances, or a period of quiescence with no noticeable changes,” depending on the child and what’s happening around them.

So this isn’t a letter to brace anybody for disaster. Most firstborns come through it fine, and some come through it taller. It’s a letter about the before, written because the before is about to end whether anyone notices or not.

Here’s the thing about that “before.” Once there are two children, every memory of your oldest gets quietly re-sorted around the second. You’ll remember that they were three when the baby came. You will not, without help, remember what the two of you did on an ordinary Tuesday when it was just them. The details go soft fast, which is the whole argument of our post on writing things down before they blur, and it applies here with unusual force.

There’s a second reason, and it’s for later. Somewhere down the road, your firstborn is going to wonder whether they were enough on their own, or whether the second baby was a replacement, an upgrade, a correction. Some kids wonder exactly that, and it’s not the kind of thing a kid says out loud. A letter written before the baby, in your hand, saying exactly what they were to you when they were the only one, answers the question before they ask it.

When to Write It

The best window is the last month or so before the baby arrives. Late enough that the change is real and the nursery exists; early enough that you’re not yet writing through the fog of night feeds. If you’re adopting or welcoming a child through foster care or placement, the equivalent is the waiting stretch, when you know it’s coming but the house hasn’t changed yet.

A few specific moments work especially well:

  • The night you pack the hospital bag. It’s already a getting-ready evening. Add one envelope.
  • After a last ordinary outing, just the two of you. The library, the playground, the drive-through where they always order the same thing. Write that evening, while the details are still on the counter.
  • The day they first say something about “my baby.” Their version of the news is worth recording in their words, misunderstandings included.

If the baby has already arrived and you’re reading this at 3 a.m., you haven’t missed it. Write it in the first few weeks, while the before is still close enough to touch, and say so in the letter.

What to Include in a Letter to Your Firstborn

You don’t need to write a lot. One or two pages is plenty, and a page of specific things beats four pages of how much you love them (they’ll know; the specifics are what they won’t have).

  1. Who they are right now. Their age in months if they’re small. The word they mispronounce. The shoes they insist on. What they’re afraid of and what they think is the funniest thing in the world.
  2. Your routine together. The bedtime order of operations. The song. The stuffed animal that has to face a specific direction. These are the things that change first when a second child shows up, so they’re the things most worth writing down.
  3. What they made you. They turned you into a parent. Say what that was like, plainly. Not as a burden, just as a fact of the record: before them, you didn’t know how to do this, and they taught you.
  4. How they took the news. What they said when you told them. What they think the baby will be like. If they’ve promised to share exactly one toy, note which one.
  5. What you hope for the two of them. Keep it light. You don’t know who the second child is yet, so you can’t promise a best friend. You can say what you hope your oldest gets out of being someone’s older sibling.
  6. What won’t change. This is the line they’ll read most carefully later, so be specific. Not “I’ll always love you,” but the particular thing you intend to keep doing with them, just the two of you, after the baby is here.
  7. An honest sentence about yourself. That you’re nervous, or tired, or worried about being enough for two. My bet is that a parent who sounds a little scared on paper is more reassuring to read later than one who sounds like a greeting card.

About that sixth item: the American Academy of Pediatrics’ advice for preparing an older child includes making “an effort to spend some time alone with them each day,” and it tells parents to “expect your child to regress a little.” If you put a promise in the letter, make it one you can actually keep on four hours of sleep. Ten minutes, the two of you, same time each day, is a better promise than a weekly outing you’ll be canceling by February.

Prompts to Get You Started

Pick two or three. Don’t answer all of them.

  • Right now, the thing you ask me for most is…
  • This is what our mornings look like, start to finish, as of this week.
  • When we told you about the baby, you said…
  • The first thing you taught me about being a parent was…
  • Here is a whole ordinary day of ours that I never want to forget.
  • The thing about you that I hope never changes is…
  • You’re going to be someone’s first person to look up to. Here’s what I think you’ll be good at.
  • This is the bedtime routine, exactly, in order, including the part where you stall.
  • Something I’m worried about, and why I think we’ll be fine.
  • Here is what I plan to keep doing with just you, after the baby comes.
  • If you’re reading this when you’re older and wondering where you fit: here’s the answer.

When to Have It Arrive

Hold My Letter holds letters for one month to two years, so the open date has to land inside that window. Inside it, three dates do most of the work:

  • Your firstborn’s next birthday. Their day, their mail. A letter that arrives addressed to them on a day already about them says, without any explanation, that they still get their own day.
  • The new baby’s first birthday. It’s also the first anniversary of your oldest becoming an older sibling, which nobody else in the family will think to mark. Have their letter arrive then and they get something on the baby’s big day that is only theirs.
  • A quiet, unremarkable day a few months in. The phase where the novelty of the baby has worn off for everyone, and the oldest is feeling it. A letter in the mailbox on a random Wednesday in that stretch can be oddly well timed.

Whichever you pick, the envelope probably shouldn’t be the end of the letter’s life. If your firstborn is small, read them the parts that land at their age, then put the letter somewhere safe for the year they can read it alone. We hold it until your date. After that, the keeping is yours, which is how it should be for a letter like this.

How Hold My Letter Makes This Easy

The hard part of a letter like this isn’t writing it. It’s that you’re writing it the same month you’re washing newborn clothes and finding the car seat base, and anything you tuck into a drawer that month is going to disappear into the drawer.

The Handwritten Future Letter ($19) is the one I’d point you to for this. Your handwriting is part of what your firstborn will want later. You write the letter by hand, mail it to us sealed, and we keep it sealed in fire-resistant, climate-controlled storage, then mail it to the address you choose on your date. Start a handwritten letter for someone else here.

If you’re short on time, or your third-trimester handwriting is not what it used to be, the Digital Future Letter ($9) works too: type it at holdmyletter.com/write, pick the date, and we print it on cream stationery, seal it with wax, and mail it. Both are a one-time payment, US addresses only, with any delivery date from one month to two years out.

If you’re also writing to the baby who’s on the way, our guide to writing a letter to your unborn child covers that one. And for the longer arc of the two of them, years from now, there’s the letter to write for your sibling, which your kids may one day write to each other.

FAQ

My firstborn can’t read yet. Is a letter still worth writing?

Yes. A two- or three-year-old won’t read it, and that’s fine. The letter isn’t really for the child they are now; it’s for the eight-year-old or the fifteen-year-old who wants to know what they were like before the family changed. For now, an envelope with their own name on it is an event. Read them the parts that make sense today and keep the rest for later.

When is the best time to write a letter to my firstborn before the new baby?

In the last month or so of the pregnancy, or during the adoption or placement wait, when the change is real but hasn’t happened yet. Once the baby is home, you’ll be too tired, and you’ll already be remembering your firstborn through the new arrangement. The point is to write while they’re still your only child.

Should the letter be addressed to my child or to me?

Either works, and they do different things. Addressed to your child, the envelope itself becomes part of the gift, which small kids love. Addressed to you, you get to read it first, decide what to share now, and put the original away for when they’re older. With a toddler, the second is usually simpler; with a child of five or older, the first is more fun.

Can Hold My Letter keep it until my child turns ten or eighteen?

No. Hold My Letter holds letters for one month to two years, never longer. For this letter, that’s a useful window: have it arrive on your firstborn’s next birthday or on the new baby’s first birthday, then keep the sealed letter in a box for the day your firstborn is old enough to read it themselves.

Should both parents write one?

If both of you can, yes, written separately. You see your firstborn from different angles, and two short letters will cover more than one long one written by committee. Don’t compare notes until they arrive.

Should I write one to the new baby too?

You can, but it’s a different letter, with different timing. This one is about the family as it was before the baby. A letter to the new baby is about the family they’re arriving into. If you want both, write them in different sittings so one doesn’t swallow the other.

Your firstborn was your whole definition of “parent” for a while. Put that in writing before the definition gets bigger.

Share this letter

✧

Ready to Write Your Letter?

Your future self (or someone you love) is waiting to hear from you.

Shop My Favorites on Benable

Everything you need to start tonight

  • Write Letters Now So People Cry Later (the Good Kind)

    A complete letter-writing kit you can start tonight: paper, pen, seal, and the nerve to begin.

    Shop the list →

Shop My Favorites on BenableLinks may earn a commission.

Related Stories

Write Your Letter